Prohibition Notice — Martin Ryan (5 years)

Prohibition
Entity
Martin Ryan
Published
–
Incident Period
–
Decision date
30 Aug 2022
Final
30 Aug 2022
Penalty
–
Legal Section
–
Sanctioning statute
Central Bank Reform Act 2010
Substantive law
Central Bank Reform Act 2010
Source regulator
CBI

Structured fields are extracted automatically. A dash means the value could not be reliably extracted; the original notice below is always complete. Sanctioning statute is the law the measure is based on; Substantive law is the law whose obligations were breached — often the same, but they differ when the sanction rests on a general provision rather than the specific rule that was broken.

Original notice text (Original)

13 April 2023

5 year prohibition issued to Martin Ryan in respect of all controlled functions, effective from 30 August 2022.

Mr Ryan is the former Chief and Signing Actuary at RSA Insurance Ireland DAC (RSAII) and former Actuarial Manager at Euro Insurances DAC (EID) trading as LeasePlan.

The Prohibition Notice (PDF) issued after Mr Ryan signed a Statement of Undisputed Facts, in which he accepted that he had facilitated an undocumented practice during his time at RSAII, which resulted in a significant shortfall in the firm’s reserves in 2013. Further, he also accepted that during a fitness and probity assessment at EID in 2016, Mr Ryan failed to provide material information and gave false and / or misleading information.

The Prohibition Notice issued to Mr Ryan prohibits him from carrying out any controlled functions, including pre-approval controlled functions, in any regulated financial service provider for a period of 5 years.

Seána Cunningham, Director of Enforcement and Anti-Money Laundering said:

"Regulated firms, and their management, have first line responsibility under the Fitness and Probity Regime, acting as a gatekeeper to the industry by ensuring people subject to the regime are fit and proper. Information provided by persons seeking to perform controlled functions during assessments of their fitness and probity must be complete and accurate.

P ersons performing controlled functions must act with honesty and integrity, in accordance with the applicable standards of fitness and probity. Where an individual is suspected to have failed to meet these standards, the Central Bank may use its statutory powers to investigate. If warranted, the Central Bank will prohibit an individual from performing controlled functions in order to uphold public trust and confidence in the financial system and protect users of financial services.”

Additional Information

The Fitness and Probity Regime was introduced by the Central Bank under the Central Bank Reform Act 2010 to ensure that regulated firms and individuals who work in these firms are committed to high standards of competence, integrity and honesty and are held to account when they fall below these standards. View further detail on the Fitness and Probity Regime, including the Fitness and Probity Standards.

Assessments of an individual’s fitness and probity to perform a controlled functions are conducted by the relevant Regulated Financial Services Provider (RFSP), with the Central Bank acting as a gatekeeper to certain senior roles called “pre-approval controlled functions” or “PCFs”, as firms may not appoint individuals to these roles without the Central Bank’s prior approval in writing.

The Central Bank may investigate individuals in controlled functions, including pre-approval controlled functions, if we suspect that they do not have the required fitness and / or probity to perform the role, and we may prohibit them following such investigation, if appropriate.


Prohibition Notice (PDF)

TO: CC: FROM: DATE: SUBJECT: Decision Prohibition Notice Banc Ceannais na hEireann Central Bank of Ireland Eurosystem Section 43 of the Central Bank Reform Act 2010 (as amended) Mr. Mar t in Ryan c/o Sherwin 0 1 Riordan Solicitors 74 Pembroke Road Dublin4 The Governor, Central Bank o f Ireland Simon Sloan, Head o f Investment Banks & Broker Dealers Division, delegate appointed by the Commission o f the Central Bank o f Ireland t o perform certain functions o f the Commission under Part 3, Chapter 4 o f the Central Bank Reform Act 2010 (as amended) 30 August 2022 Prohibition Notice Section 43 o f the Central Bank Reform Act 2010 (as amended) In accordance wit h my appointed function under Part 3, Chapter 4 o f the Central Bank Reform Act 2010 (as amended}, I hereby notify Mr. Martin Ryan (Mr. Ryan) o f my decision t o issue a prohibition notice under that Act prohibiting Mr. Ryan from performing any controlled functions (including pre approval controlled functions) in relation t o all regulated financial service providers for a period o f five years for the reasons given in this prohibition notice. 1 THIS PROHIBITION NOTICE SOLELY RELATES TO THE CONDUCT OF MR. MARTIN RYAN. NO FINDING AND/OR CRITICISM IS MADE IN RESPECT OF ANY OTHER PARTY/PERSON.

-- 1 of 22 --

Definitions The definitions below are used in this prohibition notice: Banc Ceannais na h.Eireann Central Bank of Ireland Eurosystem 2012 Regulations means the Central Bank Reform Act 2010 (Procedures Governing the Conduct o f Investigations) Regulations 2012; 2010 Act means the Central Bank Reform Act 2010 (as amended); Case Summary Report means the report dated 30 July 2021 on the fitness and probity o f Mr. Ryan prepared for the purposes o f Section 43 o f the 2010 Act; Central Bank o r Bank means the Central Bank o f Ireland; Commission means the Commission of the Central Bank; Decision Ma ker means Simon Sloan, Head o f Investment Banks & Broker Dealers Division, delegate o f the Commission o f the Central Bank appointed to perform certain functions o f the Commission under Part 3, Chapter 4 o f the 2010 Act; Deputy Governor means the Deputy Governor (Prudential Regulation) o f the Central Bank who is the Head o f Financial Regulation within the meaning o f the 2010 Act; EID means Euro Insurances DAC trading as Leaseplan Insurances; ENFI means the Enforcement Investigations Division o f the Central Bank; Governor means the Governor o f the Central Bank; Guidance on the Standards means the Guidance on Fitness and Probity Standards issued by the Central Bank under Section 50 o f the 2010 Act; Investigator means the person appointed by the Deputy Governor, pursuant to Section 52 (2) o f the 2010 Act to investigate and report through the use o f powers contained in Part 3, Chapter 3 of the 2010 Act as supplemented by the 2012 Regulations on the fitness and probity o f Mr. Ryan; Investigation means the fitness and probity investigation into Mr. Ryan in accordance wit h Section 25 o f the 2010 Act; Prohibition means the terms o f the prohibition, as indicated in the section o f this notice entitled "Scope o f prohibition notice"; Relevant SAO means any o f the SAOs for the financial years ending 31 December 2009 to 31 December 2012 inclusive, which Mr. Ryan was responsible for signing on behalf of RSAII; RSAII means RSA Insurance Ireland Limited; Statement of Actuarial Opinion o r SAO means an annual statement required by the Central Bank from non-life insurance companies in Ireland setting o u t their non-life technical 2

-- 2 of 22 --

Banc Ceannais na hEireann Central Bank of Ireland Eurosystem reserves, both gross and net o f reinsurance, f o r the purposes o f complying with their solvency requirements; Standards means the Fitness and Probity Standards, which is aCode issued under Section 50 o f the 2010 Act; Statement of Undisputed Facts means the statement o f facts signed by Mr. Ryan on 11 December 2020; and Undisputed Facts means the facts as set o u t in the Statement o f Undisputed Facts signed by Mr. Ryan on 11 December 2020. 3

-- 3 of 22 --

1. Background Banc Ceannais na hEireann Central Bank of Ireland Eurosystem I note from the Case Summary Report, which details the background in this matter, that Mr. Ryan was first employed by RSAI I as an Actuarial Pricing Manager in 2002. He was promoted t o Reserving Capital Manager in 2007. At the same time, he became a Signing Actuary for RSAII. A Signing Actuary is an actuary appointed by the company to provide an SAO. Signing an SAO requires the Signing Actuary to certify the adequacy o f the total reserves o f the company, and confirm that the company's reserves are in compliance with relevant Irish and European legislation.1 The nature o f the opinion required in an SAO places a high level o f responsibility on the Signing Actuary. The Signing Actuary must hold a valid practising certificate issued by the Society o f Actuaries in Ireland when signing an SAO consider whether he o r she has sufficient knowledge and experience to undertake the assignment, including knowledge o f the business procedures o f the company, o f the markets in which it operates and o f types o f business similar to those underwritten by the company. Mr. Ryan was appointed t o the Pre-Approval Controlled Function o f Chief Actuary (PCF-20) in September 2011. Mr. Ryan continued to act as Signing Actuary until his resignation from RSAII in Apr il 2015. As Chief Actuary, Mr. Ryan was responsible for the RSAII Reserving Team, Technical Pricing Team and Capital Team. Mr. Ryan was responsible for recommending actuarial reserves and presenting these to the Reserving Committee. He was also responsible for recommending actuarial pricing and overseeing the calculation o f RSAII capital and capital modelling. As Signing Actuary, Mr. Ryan was responsible for signing SAOs on behalf o f RSAII for the financial years ending 31 December 2009 t o 31 December 2012 inclusive (the Relevant SAOs). The guidance for a Signing Actuary providing an SAO on technical reserves at that time, included 2008 Guidance issued by the Central Bank on Actuarial Certification, which included requirements for whistle-blowing, data accuracy, integrity and sufficiency, as well as further guidance in the Actuarial Standard o f Practice on Non-Life Technical Reserves issued by the Society o f Actuaries in Ireland. On 1 October 2013, the Central Bank informed RSAI I that it had identified delays in increasing recommended claim reserve estimates on a sample o f large loss claims at RSAI I. 1 Non-life insurance companies in Ireland are required t o provide the Central Bank with a Statement o f Actuarial Opinion (SAO) on an annual basis, setting o u t their non-life technical reserves, both gross and net o f reinsurance, for the purposes o f complying with the ir solvency requirements. Technical Reserves are the amount set aside by an insurance company to cover its liability for claims. Technical Reserves comprise an aggregate o f Outstanding Claims Reserve, Unearned Premium Reserve and Unexpired Risk Reserve. 4

-- 4 of 22 --

Banc Ceannai s na hEireann Central Bank of Ireland Eurosystem RSAII is wholly owned by RSA Insurance Group pie (RSA Group). In 2013, RSA Group commenced an investigation into a number o f issues at RSAII. The investigation was referred t o as Project White. Project White found that between 2009 and 2013, certain individuals within RSAII were manipulating claim reserve estimates. They did this by recording estimates on the claims database that were significantly lower than claim handlers' recommendations and/or significantly delaying the recording o f the claim reserve estimate increases recommended by the claims handlers in relation to certain large loss claims. Project White referred to this process as the Under-Reserving Practice. Project White also found that there was alist (the List) that detailed the existing claim reserve estimates for certain large loss claims recorded on RSAll's claims database, as well as the claims handlers' recommended claim reserve estimates for these claims which were not recorded. In al e t t e r dated 20June 2014, RSAII informed Mr. Ryan that, following the findings o f Project White, a number o f allegations o f misconduct had been made against him. A date was set for a disciplinary hearing which ultimately did not proceed due to the resignation o f Mr. Ryan as set o u t below. On 17 February 2015, the Financial Reporting Council (FRC), which is the independent disciplinary body for actuarial professions in the UK, commenced an investigation into Mr. Ryan's conduct regarding his actuarial work at RSAII (the FRC Investigation). Mr. Ryan was informed o f that decision by letter dated 23 March 2015. Mr. Ryan resigned from RSAII on 15 April 2015 as part o f asettlement agreement with RSAI I. On 13 December 2016, a Settlement Agreement and "Particulars o f Facts" and "Acts o f Misconduct" were agreed between Mr. Ryan and the Executive Council o f the FRC. The "Particulars o f Facts and Acts o f Misconduct" set o u t the admissions made by Mr. Ryan in respect o f his conduct, including the following: i. He was incompetent in submitting Statements o f Actuarial Opinion to the Financial Regulator/ the Central Bank, which were based on inaccurate data due to the Under- Reserving Practice; and ii. He failed t o whistle-blow regarding the Under-Reserving Practice o r sufficiently challenge his colleagues in relation to it. As part o f his settlement with the FRC, Mr. Ryan agreed not to undertake the performance o f any Pre-Approval Controlled Function (PCF), o r any Controlled Function (CF), as defined by the Central Bank, other than a CF-2 under the supervision o f an actuary performing a PCF o r CF-1 role in the Republic o f Ireland for the period of 3 years. In December 2015, following his resignation from RSAII, Mr. Ryan was engaged as an independent contractor by EID, by way o f Supplier Agreements between EID and Mr. Ryan's company, Ballyveelish Analytics Limited. 5

-- 5 of 22 --

Banc Ceannais na h.Eireann Central Bank of Ireland Eurosystem Mr. Ryan submitted invoices t o EID on a monthly basis from September 2016 onwards in respect o f actuarial services provided by him. These services included controlled function activities in his role as Actuarial Manager for EID. EID conducted an assessment o f Mr. Ryan's fitness and probity to perform aCF-2 role for the firm in March 2016 (the F&P Assessment} and Mr. Ryan was engaged by EID until 10 April 2020. On 8 January 2017, the Society o f Actuaries in Ireland reprimanded Mr. Ryan following an investigation and his acceptance that misconduct had occurred, which was published on the Society's website until 9 January 2020. A number o f determinations and recommendations were made, which Mr. Ryan accepted, On 18 December 2018, following the conclusion o f an investigation under the Central Bank's Administrative Sanctions Procedure (ASP}, RSAII was fined €3.5 million by the Central Bank (the ASP Investigation}. This followed admissions by RSAII relating to afailure by the firm t o maintain technical reserves and its failure t o have sound and adequate administrative, accounting and robust governance procedures in place. The ASP Investigation against RSAII commenced in 2014 and identified extensive issues within RSAll's Claims and Finance functions. The ASP Investigation identified the deliberate and systematic under-reserving o f certain large loss claims (the Under-Reserving Practice}, which led to an understatement in the RSAll's Technical Reserves as at 30 September 2013. The Central Bank published a detailed statement following the conclusion o f the ASP Investigation against RSAII. The statement described the operation o f the Under-Reserving Practice and by way o f example, referred to apersonal injuries claim that had arecommended claim reserve estimate o f €4,750,000, but the amount actually recorded on RSAll's claims database was only €20,000. On 17 October 2018, Mr. Ryan was notified that the Central Bank was minded to commence an investigation into his fitness and probity by way o f the Notice o f Intention. 6

-- 6 of 22 --

Banc Ceannais na hEireann Central Bank of Ireland Eurosystem On 22 February 2019, the Central Bank issued the Notice o f Commencement t o Mr. Ryan, informing him ofthedecisiontocommencethe Investigation. Mr. Ryan provided submissions in response to the Notice of Intention, dated on 8 November 2018. The Notice o f Commencement was also issued to his employers at EID. At the time o f the commencement o f the F&P Investigation Mr. Ryan was performing a controlled function for the firm in his role as Actuarial Manager. On 14 March 2019, EID suspended the performance o f actuarial services provided to the firm by Mr. Ryan pending the outcome o f the Central Bank's F&P Investigation. Mr. Ryan formally ended his engagement with EID on 10 April 2020. In an email dated 24April 2020, El D's Head o f Legal, Risk and Compliance informed the Central Bank that M r Ryan had resigned. On 11 December 2020, Mr. Ryan signed a Statement of Undisputed Facts with the Central Bank detailed in the Prohibition section below. The Investigator prepared a Case Summary Report dated 30 July 2021. The contents o f the Case Summary Report were sent (in draft form) to Mr. Ryan's solicitors, Sherwin O'Riordan, by lette r dated 21 May 2021 for their submissions. Submissions were received in reply from Mr. Ryan's solicitors on 22 July 2021 (the submissions). The Case Summary Report requested the Decision Maker to consider the facts and matters agreed in the Statement o f Undisputed Facts, any submissions provided by Mr. Ryan, and t o make a decision in relation to the following issues: Issue 1 Does the Decision Maker agree that no further investigation is necessary? Issue 2 Does Mr. Ryan lack sufficient fitness and probity to carry out a controlled function? Issue 3 ls it necessary to issue a prohibition notice? Submissions in response to the Case Summary Report were provided by Mr. Ryan by his solicitor, Sherwin O'Riordan, in a letter dated 22 July 2021. I was appointed by the Commission o f the Central Bank t o perform the functions of the Central Bank under Part 3 Chapter 4 o f the 2010 Act (including under Section 43). The Case Summary Report and associated documents, including the correspondence wit h and submissions made by o r on behalf of Mr. Ryan, have been furnished to me. On 21 December 2021, I decided that there were undisputed facts that rendered the continuation o f the Investigation unnecessary and a copy o f this decision was sent t o Mr. Ryan's solicitors Sherwin O'Riordan solicitors on that date. I have now considered the remaining issues. On 10 June 2022, a Notification o f Proposed Prohibition Notice (the NPPN) was delivered t o Sherwin O'Riordan solicitors. The NPPN allowed for the making o f submissions in relation t o this prohibition on o r before 5pm on 15 July 2022. Sherwin O'Riordan solicitors requested an extension o f time o f four weeks for submissions by email dated 14 July 2022 and on my behalf, the Regulatory Decisions Unit (RDU) of the Central Bank wrote to Sherwin O'Riordan indicating my agreement to extend the time for submissions t o 12 August 2022. By email dated 12 August 2022, Sherwin O'Riordan Requested a further one week extension of time 7

-- 7 of 22 --

Banc Ceannais na hEireann Central Bank of Ireland Eurosystem to 19 August 2022, to which request RDU indicated my agreement by email dated 16 August 2022. On 18 August 2022, Sherwin O'Riordan emailed RDU setting out that Mr. Ryan "will not be lodging any further Submissions" in relation t o this notice and no such submissions were received. 8

-- 8 of 22 --

2. Consideration of Key Statutory Requirements Section 43 (1) of the 2010 Act provides: Banc Ceannais na hEireann Central Bank of Ireland Eurosystem "Subject to subsection (4), if the Bank or Governor has reasonably formed the opinion that a person is not o fsuch fitness and probity as is appropriate to perform a particular controlled function, a specified part o f a controlled function or any controlled function, the Bank or Governor, as the case may be, may issue a notice in writing (in this Part called a "prohibition notice") forbidding the person - (a) to carry out the controlled function, the specified part o f a controlled function or any controlled function, as the case requires, or (b) to carry out the controlled function, the specified part of such a function or any controlled function, as the case requires, otherwise than in accordance with a specified condition or conditions, either for a specified period or indefinitely." Section 43 (2) of the 2010 Act sets o u t a list o f broad categories which may constitute a lack o f fitness and probity. These include Section 43 (2) (b} where "the person does not satisfy an applicable standard o f fitness and probity in a code issued pursuant to section 50" (i.e. the Standards] and Section 43 (2} (c) which refers to the person having "participated in serious misconduct in relation to the business o f a regulated financial service provider". Section 43 (3) of the 2010 Act sets o u t that the Bank o r the Governor shall not issue a prohibition notice, unless certain criteria are met. Specifically, section 43 (3} (a} (ii} provides that: "The Bank or the Governor shall not issue a prohibition notice in relation to a person unless there are undisputed facts that in the reasonable opinion o f the Bank or the Governor render an investigation unnecessary, and the person and any regulated financial service provider concerned have been afforded a reasonable opportunity to make a submission in relation to the matter." Section 43 (3) (b) of the 2010 Act provides that the Bank o r the Governor shall not issue a prohibition notice in relation to a person unless "the person and the regulated financial service provider have been afforded such a hearing in relation to the proposed issue o f the prohibition notice as is necessary to do justice in the circumstances...". Section 43 (3) (c) of the 2010 Act provides that the Bank o r the Governor shall not issue a prohibition notice in relation to a person unless satisfied that the issue o f a prohibition notice is necessary in the circumstances. Section 43 (4) of the 2010 Act provides that when considering whether to issue a prohibition notice, the Bank (or the Governor, as the case may be} shall have particular regard to the need 9

-- 9 of 22 --

Banc Ceannais na hEireann Central Bank of Ireland Eurosystem t o prevent potential serious damage to the financial system in the State and ensure the continued stability o f that system and the need to protect users o f financial services. Section 43 (12) (a) of the 2010 Act provides that a prohibition notice should not continue for longer than is necessary to achieve the purposes o f Part 3 o f the 2010 Act. The Standards as issued by the Central Bank require as follows: "2.1. A person to whom this Code applies shall comply with these Standards at all times. 2.2. In order to comply with Section 2.1, a person is required to be: a) competent and capable; b) honest, ethical and to act with integrity; and c) financially sound." The Guidance on the Standards provides that in determining the standard o f probity, individuals must be "honest, diligent and independent-minded and must act ethically and with integrity". 10

-- 10 of 22 --

3. Prohibition Banc Ceannais na hEireann Central Bank of Ireland Eurosystem In determining whether a prohibition was necessary in this case, the following factors were considered in formulating my decision: Such hearing as is necessary to do iustice in the circumstances I am satisfied that Mr. Ryan has been afforded such hearing in relation to the proposed issue o f the prohibition notice as is necessary to do justice in the circumstances and I confirm that I have considered all o f the submissions made by Mr. Ryan. There were no submissions received to the NPPN dated 10 June 2022. I have also considered that Mr. Ryan signed a Statement o f Undisputed Facts and therefore made substantial admissions in this case. The fitness & probity o f Mr. Ryan Having carefully considered all aspects o f this matter, I have formed the view that Mr. Ryan is not o f such fitness and probity as is appropriate to carry out any controlled function in accordance with Section 43 (1) o f the 2010 Act for the reasons as set out below. As noted above, Mr. Ryan signed a Statement of Undisputed Facts on 11 December 2020, confirming that: i. He facilitated the wrongful Under-Reserving Practice at RSAII for a period in excess o f three years by making various actuarial adjustments which were not documented o r reported; ii. He failed to demonstrate proper regard for key governance procedures at RSAI I; iii. He signed and submitted inaccurate Statements o f Actuarial Opinion to the Central Bank on behalf o f RSAII for the years 2009-2012; iv. He failed to comply with his whistle-blower obligations and make a report in respect o f the Under-Reserving Practice at RSAII or the issues in relation to the inaccurate Statements o f Actuarial Opinion; v. He made false statements during the Project White interview on 31 October 2013; and vi. He made false and misleading statements and failed to disclose material information during his fitness and probity assessment at EID. I confirm that I have considered Section 43 (2) of the 2010 Act, which sets out a list o f circumstances which may constitute a lack o f fitness and probity. I note in particular that Section 43 (2) (b) provides for where "the person does not satisfy an applicable standard o f fitness and probity in a code issued pursuant to section 50" (i.e. the Standards). Specifically, I note that paragraph 2.2 o f the Standards provide that a person is required t o be, inter a/ia, honest, ethical and to act with integrity. In this regard, I am satisfied that Mr. Ryan's failure to act honestly, ethically and with integrity, is in breach o f the Standards for the reasons set o u t in detail below. 11

-- 11 of 22 --

Banc Ceannais na hEireann Central Bank of Ireland Eu rosystem I have also considered Section 43 (2) (d) o f the 2010 Act which refers to a person "directly or indirectly provided information that the person knew or ought to have known was false or misleading to another person in order for it to be provided to the Bank, the Governor or the Head o f Financial Regulation". Based on the considerations detailed below, I am satisfied that Mr. Ryan's conduct fell far short o f the standards expected by the Fitness & Probity Regime. In addition, Section 43 (2) (c) o f the 2010 Act refers to the person having"participated in serious misconduct in relation to the business o f a regulated financial service provider". I am satisfied that knowingly submitting inaccurate returns to the Central Bank over a protracted period and facilitating the continuation o f the Under-Reserving Practice amounts to serious misconduct based on the following facts: i. Facilitation o f the Under-Reserving Practice I have considered that Mr. Ryan was aware o f the Under-Reserving Practice from 2009 onwards, participated in meetings at which the List was discussed between 2009 and 2013 and that he failed to sufficiently challenge his colleagues in relation to the Under-Reserving Practice. By so failing to sufficiently challenge his colleagues and in making adjustments t o take account o f the under-reserved claims, he facilitated the continued operation o f the Under-Reserving Practice for a period in excess o f three years. As set o u t above and detailed in the Case Summary Report, RSAII was fined €3.5 million by the Central Bank in respect o f breaches offinancial services legislation (including a breach of the requirement to maintain technical reserves in accordance with regulatory requirements). The Central Bank's investigation found that the deliberate and systematic under-reserving o f large loss claims (i.e. the Under-Reserving Practice) directly contributed to the firm's breach. Mr. Ryan has admitted that his actions facilitated the continued operation o f the Under-Reserving Practice for over three years. As aresult, I have considered Section 43 (2) (c) o f the 2010 Act which refers to a person having "participated in serious misconduct in relation to the business o f a regulated financial service provider" and am o f the opinion that Mr. Ryan participated in serious misconduct in relation to the business o f RSAII. ii. Failure to have proper regard for governance procedures Mr. Ryan failed to demonstrate proper regard for key governance procedures and controls. As outlined in the Case Summary Report, Mr. Ryan made actuarial adjustments in relation t o RSAll's "Incurred But Not Reported" claims. This is afigure calculated in respect o f insurance claims where liability has arisen but the claim has not yet been reported to the insurer, or it has been reported but there is insufficient information to reliably estimate the ultimate cost. The adjustments were not documented nor were they shared via official reporting channels. In that regard, I am o f the view that Mr. Ryan failed t o demonstrate proper regard for key governance procedures. The importance o f the adherence to strong governance procedures and controls by those in senior management, a role that Mr. Ryan held, is critical to the proper function and effective operation o f regulated entities t o ensure compliance with all appropriate rules, regulations and requirements. 12

-- 12 of 22 --

iii. Inaccurate Statements o fActuarial Opinion Banc Ceannais na hEireann Central Bank of Ireland Eurosystem The submission o f regulatory information to the Central Bank is an important responsibility o f regulated entities. In carrying out its statutory responsibilities o f safeguarding financial stability and protecting consumers, the accurate and timely submission of regulatory returns is o f critical important in the discharge o f its responsibilities. I note that Mr. Ryan was appointed to the Pre-Approval Controlled Function o f Chief Actuary {PCF-20) in September 2011. Mr. Ryan continued t o act as Signing Actuary until his resignation from RSAII in April 2015. As Chief Actuary, M r. Ryan was responsible for the RSAII Reserving Team, Technical Pricing Team and Capital Team. Mr. Ryan was also responsible for recommending actuarial reserves and presenting these to the Reserving Committee. He was also responsible for recommending actuarial pricing and overseeing the calculation o f RSAII capital and capital modelling. As Signing Actuary, as noted above, Mr. Ryan was responsible for signing SAOs on behalf o f RSAII for the financial years ending 31 December 2009 to 31 December 2012 inclusive {the Relevant SAOs). Mr. Ryan was aware o f the Under-Reserving Practice at RSAII from 2009 onwards and participated in meetings at which the List was discussed between 2009 and 2013. The Relevant SAOs submitted by him on behalf o f RSAII for years ending 2009-2012 inclusive, were based on information that was inaccurate and included astatement which had tt,e effect o f being misleading. In signing the Relevant SAOs, which Mr. Ryan accepts contained inaccurate information, I am satisfied that Mr. Ryan knew o r ought to have known that the information he was providing to the Central Bank was misleading. Regulatory' returns are atool used by the Central Bank to monitor the financial position o f credit institutions and the risks to which they are exposed. The submission o f inaccurate information undermines the Central Bank's ability to properly supervise firms. I have given further consideration to the additional expectation on Mr. Ryan, due to the seniority o f the role held by him as the Pre-Approval Controlled Function o f Chief Actuary {PCF-20). In respect o f his fitness, Mr. Ryan admits that he demonstrated significant incompetence in his role as Chief and Signing Actuary at RSAII, by submitting the Relevant SAOs on behalf o f RSAII for years ending 2009-2012 using data that were inaccurate. In knowingly facilitating the submission o f inaccurate data to the Central Bank on behalf o f RSAII for years ending 2009-2012, I have concluded that Mr. Ryan's actions had the potential t o undermine the ability o f the Central Bank to discharge its statutory responsibilities. iv. Failure to comply with whistle-blower obligations While acknowledging Mr Ryan's submissions regarding the evolution o f the legal protections for whistle-blowers, I am satisfied that there were appropriate channels open t o Mr. Ryan {through his employer at Group level and to the Central Bank) to report on the observed stated practices. While legislation has subsequently provided for greater protection for whistle-blowers, I have not seen evidence o f Mr. Ryan seeking t o inform his employer (through the group reporting mechanisms) o r the Central Bank {via the supervisory team) o f the wrongdoing and I consider that a senior executive would have sufficient experience t o 13

-- 13 of 22 --

Banc Ceannais na hEireann Central Bank of Ireland Eurosystem understand and make use o f the avenues o f reporting available t o Mr. Ryan, irrespective o f legislative provisions. v. Project White Interview - false statements I note that during and internal investigation (Project White) at RSAII regarding the Under - Reserving Practice that Mr. Ryan made false and misleading statements during an interview on 31 October 2013. In seeking to engage in a manner that lacked full honesty, integrity and transparency, I am satisfied that Mr. Ryan acted in a manner that falls far short o f what is expected in such circumstances. Mr. Ryan had a duty o f care to his employer to engage in an honest, open and truthful manner in his engagement on this investigation. vi. EID F&P assessments I note that during an assessment o f his fitness and probity at EID in respect o f a role that included the performance o f a controlled function, Mr. Ryan made false declarations, failed t o provide material information, and made misleading statements in respect o f matters relevant to his fitness and probity. In the Statement o f Undisputed Facts, Mr. Ryan admits t o providing false and misleading statements during the F&P Assessment carried out by EID in 2016. I have concluded that in taking such actions, Mr. Ryan did not demonstrate that he had understood the importance o f acting with integrity in the completion o f reporting t o be submitted to the Central Bank. By not submitting accurate and complete information in an application form submitted to EID demonstrates a failure to display the required degree o f honesty, integrity, competence and capability. As outlined in the Statement o f Undisputed Facts, it was preceded by a pattern o f behaviour which failed to meet the expected standards o f fitness and probity. I am satisfied, therefore that the provision of false and misleading information by Mr. Ryan during the F&P Assessment does not appear to be an isolated once- off e r r o r or occurrence. In consideration o f the behaviours that lack sufficient 'fitness', I note the continuation o f breaches o f the expected standards. Mr. Ryan engaged in a pattern o f providing false/misleading information even aft e r the under-reserving was uncovered such that: 1. RSAII commenced an internal investigation (Project White) in 2013 2. Mr. Ryan made false statements in interviews during this investigation (Oct 2013) 3. Mr. Ryan was notified o f allegations o f wrongdoing on 20 June 2014 4. FRC commenced an investigation in February 2015 and notified Mr Ryan on 23 March 2015 5. Mr. Ryan resigned from RSAII on 15 April 2015 by way o f a settlement agreement before a scheduled disciplinary hearing 6. Mr. Ryan gave incomplete/misleading/false information to EID during 2016 In December 2016, Mr. Ryan signed asettlement with FRC acknowledging wrongdoing. 14

-- 14 of 22 --

Previous regulatory decisions Banc Ceannais na hEireann Central Bank of Ireland Eurosystem a. Settlement agreement with the UK Financial Reporting Council (FRC) As referenced above, I note that an independent investigation was conducted by the UK FRC, which is the independent disciplinary body for actuarial professions, concluded by way o f Settlement Agreement, on 16 December 2016. The investigation was regarding Mr. Ryan's conduct during his actuarial work at RSAII. In that case, the admitted acts o f misconduct, as detailed in the Settlement Agreement related to his: i. Incompetence in submitting SAOs t o the Central Bank / Financial Services Regulatory Authority that were inaccurate due to the Under-Reserving Practice; and ii. Failure to whistle-blow regarding the Under-Reserving Practice, o r sufficiently challenge his colleagues in respect o f it. · As part o f his settlement wit h the FRC, Mr. Ryan agreed not t o undertake the performance o f any, PCF or any CF, as defined by the Central Bank, other than a CF-2 under the supervision o f an actuary performing a PCF o r CF-1 role in the Republic o f Ireland for a period o f 3 years. b. Reprimand issued by the Society ofActuaries in Ireland · On 8 January 2017, the Society o f Actuaries in Ireland reprimanded Mr. Ryan following an investigation and his acceptance that misconduct had occurred, which was published on the Society's website until 9 January 2020. A number o f determinations and recommendations were made, which Mr. Ryan accepted 15

-- 15 of 22 --

4. Necessity Banc Ceannais na hEireann Central Bank of Ireland Eurosystem I have concluded that it is necessary in the circumstances o f this case to issue a prohibition notice. In coming to this conclusion, I have: i. Had regard to the requirements o f Section 43 (4) o f the 2010 Act; ii. Given particular consideration to the need to prevent potential serious damage to the financial system in the State and ensure the continued stability of the system and to the need to protect users o f financial services; iii. Considered the Statement of Undisputed Facts dated 11 December 2020, the submissions and the Case Summary Report dated 30 July 2021; iv. Considered Section 43 (2) o f the 2010 Act, in particular Section 43 (2) (b), and paragraph 2.2. o f the Standards in considering the admitted facts o f this case, as noted above; v. Considered the contextual issues raised in Mr. Ryan's submissions dated 22 July 2021. In particular, I note that he advised that he was aware o f and facilitated the Under-Reserving Practice at RSAII but he had no part in the compilation o r design o f that practice; vi. Noted that Mr. Ryan also states that he did raise concerns with members of the Senior Management Team and noted the difficult and oppressive nature o f the working environment; vii. Noted that Mr. Ryan cooperated with the Central Bank during the investigation; viii. Considered Mr. Ryan's submissions regarding the evolution o f the legal protections for whistle-blowers; ix. Carefully considered the significance and outcomes o f previous investigations into Mr. Ryan, including the previous FRC reprimand o f three years in respect o f the two grounds of misconduct identified in that case. I also considered how Mr. Ryan agreed not to undertake the performance o f any PCF, or CF, other than a CF-2 under the supervision o f an actuary performing a PCF or CF-1 role in the Republic o f Ireland for the period o f 3 years. I conclude that it is necessary in the circumstances o f this case to issue a prohibition notice for the reasons set out below, having had regard to the requirements o f Section 43 (4) o f the 2010 Act. In particular, I have given consideration to the need t o prevent potential serious damage to the financial system in the State and ensure the continued stability o f the system and to the need to protect users o f financial services. Mr. Ryan occupied a senior position in a significant insurance undertaking. He had a particular onus t o ensure that the affairs of such a significant undertaking were conducted properly and in accordance with regulatory requirements. The maintenance o f confidence in financial services is vital, particularly where other significant entities have collapsed due to failures t o comply with regulatory obligations along these lines. Such conduct could potentially cause seriously damage o r destabilise the financial system. It is vital therefore that users o f financial services and the financial system have confidence that such behaviour will not be accepted. 16

-- 16 of 22 --

5. Mitiga ting/Aggravating Factors Banc Ceannais na hEireann Central Bank of Ireland Eurosystem Mr. Ryan has been afforded an opportunity t o make submissions on the matters under investigation and as noted above I confirm that I have considered his submissions o f 22 July 2021. In particular, I note that Mr. Ryan cooperated with the Central Bank during the investigation. While I would expect such cooperation t o be forthcoming o f all persons engaging with all regulatory bodies, it is important for me to note this cooperation. It should be stated that failure to cooperate fully with the Central bank would not be in keeping wit h the expectations under the Fitness & Probity Standards. I have given full consideration to the contextual matters (both professional and personal} raised in the submissions, and also to the actions and inactions o f Mr. Ryan against that backdrop o f information. I have however concluded that Mr. Ryan's conduct at issue goes to the heart o f the Fitness and Probity Standards and that it is vital, that users o f financial services have confidence that such behaviour will not be accepted. In order t o comply wit h the Fitness and Probity Standards, a person to whom the Code applies is required t o b e ' honest, ethical and act with integrity'. The stability o f the financial system is based on trus t and when undesirable conduct is identified, it is critical that all persons in roles o f responsibility act with honesty in stopping such conduct from continuing at the earliest possible opportunity. In reaching this conclusion, I have considered certain issues raised by Mr. Ryan in the submissions as set out below. The impact of the FRC sanction i. I note Mr. Ryan's submissions on the FRC sanction (where he contends it is not necessary to issue a prohibition notice as the FRC has already imposed sanctions applicable in Ireland and which addressed the public interest in full}. ii. I note that the FRC sanction did not cover all o f the grounds o f misconduct present in this case. I further note that Mr. Ryan provided misleading information to EID and the Central Bank after the Project White internal RSAII investigation and aft e r the FRC investigation commenced (Mr. Ryan was made aware of the FRC investigation by letter dated 23 March 2015). I am satisfied that these actions go beyond what could be considered 'oversight' and Mr. Ryan was aware o f his actions not being in compliance with behaviours expected. iii. The Central Bank is not restricted from imposing a prohibition against Mr. Ryan in circumstances where the FRC has already imposed a sanction. The Central Bank has appropriate jurisdiction to impose prohibitions in order to protect the stability o f the Irish financial system and users o f financial services. iv. I have however taken into account the FRC sanction in reaching my decision on the prohibition and have reflected the time-period o f the three year suspension on My Ryan through the FRC sanction. 17

-- 17 of 22 --

The assertion o f an oppressive work environment Banc Ceannais na hEireann Central Bank of Ireland Eurosystem i. I have considered Mr. Ryan's submissions on the oppressive work environment and as presented, are not as an excuse for Mr. Ryan's actions, but rather as context to them (para. 4 o f the submissions). The points made are as follows: While he did not report or directly challenge the Under-Reserving Practice, he was not responsible for it; He did raise concerns about the practice wit h members o f the EMT and and his view that any attempt to report the Practice to RSA UK and Western Europe would lead to his dismissal (paras. 6-10 o f the submissions); While he was responsible for a failure o f judgment and significant incompetence in signing the SAOs, he placed reliance on data and assurance from the CFO as to the materiality threshold (paras. 11-13 o f the submissions). In considering this position, I have concluded that Mr. Ryan's awareness o f the practice before becoming signing actuary should have been such a material red flag to him in accepting the role and/or seeking to ensure a discontinuation o f the practice before the acceptance o f the role. ii. The core function o f the Fitness and Probity Regime is to ensure that individuals in key and customer facing positions (referred t o in the legislation as CFs and PCFs) within a Regulated Financial Service Provider (Regulated Firm) are competent and capable, honest, ethical and of integrity and also financially sound. The protection o f consumer is critically dependent on the actions by senior individuals (CFs & PCFs) to ensure that no action is taken that could undermine this key objective. I am satisfied that the standards o f the Fitness and Probity Regime are such that Mr. Ryan was acutely aware o f the actions (incepted by others) being undertaken in RSAI I prior to his acceptance o f the Head o f Actuary Role. In accepting the more senior role and continuing the conduct at issue, Mr. Ryan's direct actions had a negative impact on the protection o f consumers by RSAI I and undermined the integrity o f the financial system (through the misreporting o f the financial statements o f a significant insurance entity in the State). Working in an oppressive environment was clearly a notable challenge for Mr. Ryan. However in choosing t o be a party to the continuation o f the poor behaviours in RSAI I, Mr. Ryan's selected career progression over selecting a course o f action to seek to stop the poor and inappropriate behaviours giving rise to the Under-Reserving Practice. I consider it to be a reasonable expectation o f senior roles holders (PCF and CF) t o act as an additional layer o f protection against wrongdoing for the financial 18

-- 18 of 22 --

Banc Ceannais na hEireann Central Bank of Ireland Eurosystem system and users o f financial services. I am o f the view that in not acting t o stop the wrong-doing that Mr. Ryan did not fulfil the reasonable exception o f such a senior role. The different legislative landscape for whistle-blower protection i. I note that Mr. Ryan has stated that there was adifferent legislative landscape for whistle-blower protection at the time, which I fully accept. I do however note that there was strong precedence for the importance o f whistle-blowing that Mr. Ryan has not referenced, including the guidance for aSigning Actuary providing an SAO on technical reserves at that time (included 2008 Guidance issued by the Central Bank on Actuarial Certification) included requirements for whistle-blowing, data accuracy, integrity and sufficiency, as well as further guidance in the Actuarial Standard o f Practice on Non-Life Technical Reserves issued by the Society o f Actuaries in Ireland. Mr. Ryan accepted promotions during the period he was aware o f the Under-Reserving Practice, which is an action that shows at a minimum a tacit acceptance o f the practice. ii. I am satisfied that the fact that the legislation evolved does not retrospectively negate obligations to whistle-blow and that the knowledge o f wrong-doing could have been brought forward within the RSA group o r t o the Central Bank anonymously. Mr. Ryan was not involved in the compilation or design of the Under-Reserving Practice i. I have reflected on the assertion that Mr. Ryan stated that he was not involved in the compilation o r design o f the Under-Reserving Practice. It is a point I fully accept and it is my option that had Mr. Ryan been involved in this action that m y consideration o f the sanction would be more stringent. I am however satisfied that, in enabling the Under-Reserving Practice, and instead supporting it that Mr. Ryan demonstrated judgment that fell far short o f what is expected o f a person in his position. The protection o f consumers is critically dependent on having people in senior roles in regulated entities that act in afit and proper manner at all times. Mr. Ryan's evidence tha t he did raise concerns about tha tpractice with members of the EMT i. I note that Mr. Ryan detailed the fact that he did raise concerns about the practice with members o f the EMT. I do consider that this demonstrates an awareness, by Mr. Ryan that that actions/activities in RSAI I were not in keeping o f the legislative requirement o r expected good practice. I consider these actions taken by Mr. Ryan positively. ii. I am satisfied that in not pursuing this further with EMT, and in subsequently knowingly acting in a manner that Mr. Ryan clearly knew t o be wrong does demonstrate that Mr. Ryan did not seek t o influence a cessation o f the negative actions. I have therefore concluded also that Mr. Ryan was an integral actor in the 19

-- 19 of 22 --

Banc Ceannais na hEireann Central Bank of Ireland Eurosystem continuation o f the wrong behaviours/actions that had the potential to cause significantly negative outcomes for the firm, the customers of RSAI I and the financial system. It is not apparent how it can excuse o r mitigate any aspect o f the conduct wit h which this notice is concerned. 2 0

-- 20 of 22 --

6. Scope of prohibition notice Banc Ceannais na hEireann Central Bank of Ireland Eurosystem In accordance with Section 43 (12) (a) o f the 2010 Act I am cognisant o f the requirement that a prohibition notice should not continue for longer than is necessary to achieve the purposes o f Part 3 o f the 2010 Act and o f the requirement that the prohibition notice should be proportionate in all the circumstances. I consider it imperative that holders o f controlled functions understand their roles and responsibilities and can demonstrate honest and ethical behaviour. I am o f the view that Mr. Ryan has not demonstrated honest and ethical behaviour nor has he acted with the integrity expected o f a person in a senior PCF role for the reasons set out above in section 3. Probity applies to all functions. For the following reasons, I have concluded that the prohibition notice should apply as follows: i. Mr. Ryan should not act as a CF for the period of five years. In coming to this conclusion, I have had regard to: (a) The level o f seriousness of the admitted misconduct my Mr. Ryan; (b) The fact that the misconduct is below the standard expected o f persons performing controlled functions; (c) The fact that the misconduct demonstrates afundamental lack o f judgment required and expected o f persons undertaking 'CF' and 'PCF' roles; (d) The fact that the misconduct came to light despite no actions been taken by Mr. Ryan to notify his employer o r the Central Bank of the serious misconduct he was aware o f inRSAII; (e) The fact that provision o f false and misleading information, as overseen by Mr. Ryan, was not an isolated incident but a practice that he permitted t o continue for a prolonged period; (f) Mr. Ryan facilitated the Under-Reserving Practice in RSAII over a prolonged period o f time and did not seek to notify his employer o r the Central Bank o f Ireland o f these practices, which Mr. Ryan knew to be misleading; (g) The FRC prohibition already imposed and served by Mr. Ryan for a period o f three years; (h) The fact that any such prohibition should allow for an individual to learn from their mistakes and be able t o apply for a CF role at a future point in time (should they so choose to do so) and that Mr. Ryan has aworking career ahead o f him. 21

-- 21 of 22 --

Banc Ceannais na hEireann Central Bank of Ireland Eurosystem I am satisfied that a core element o f the Standards states that "a person is required to be competent and capable; honest, ethical and to act with integrity; and financially sound. 11 I have come to the opinion that Mr. Ryan's conduct does not demonstrate compliance with these standards for the reasons set o u t above. In the operation o f the Fitness and Probity Regime, which seeks t o protect the public and ensure t r u s t in the financial system, honesty and integrity are explicit requirements for all persons holding controlled functions. Public t r u s t in the financial system is not simply achieved through rules and regulations but by the fitness and probity o f those persons working in the system to do the right thing at the right time. I am satisfied that Mr. Ryan is not o f such fitness and probity as is appropriate t o perform any controlled function and, that it is necessary in the circumstances, t o issue a prohibition notice against him. My decision is that the prohibition should be for a five year period to reflect the seriousness o f the fitness and probity issues. The issue o f publication o f this prohibition notice will be considered separately by the Central Bank. In accordance with Section 43 (7) o f the 2010 Act, the terms o f this prohibition notice take effect on the date o f service on Mr. Ryan. Signed: Simon Sloan Central Bank of Ireland 22

-- 22 of 22 --

Related

Search Martin Ryan in the ESMA sanctions register →

EU-level sanctions and enforcement actions published by ESMA and national competent authorities across the EEA.

Classifications are rule-based, not legal interpretations. Verify against the source before relying on this record.

📋 Track EU financial regulation continuously

Forseti monitors EU financial regulation and delivers personalised alerts anchored to verified official sources.

30-day free trial. No credit card required.